Rubric Nation by Tenam-Zemach, Michelle; Flynn, Joseph E., Jr.;

Short description:

This book critically examines rubrics in teacher education and evaluation, exploring their rise, strengths, weaknesses, and impact on education. It aims to spur discussion on the phenomenon of rubrics, offering critical reflections rather than best practices, and expanding the discourse on this ubiquitous evaluation tool.

Long description:

What is a rubric and how are they being used in teacher education and evaluation? When did rubrics become ubiquitous in the field of education? What impact do rubrics have on students, teachers, teacher educators, and the educational enterprise? This book is an edited volume of essays that critically examine the phenomenon of rubrics in teacher education, evaluation and education more broadly. Rubrics have seen a dramatic rise in use and presence over the past twenty-five years in colleges of education and districts across the country. Although there is a wealth of literature about how to make rubrics, there is scant literature that explores the strengths and weaknesses of rubrics and the impact the rubric phenomenon is having in reshaping education. The chapters included in this edited volume will critically reflect on the contemporary contexts of rubrics and the uses and impact of rubrics in education. Since rubrics have become indelible in education, it is necessary for a fuller, nuanced discussion of the phenomenon. Creating a book that explores these aspects of rubrics is timely and fundamental to expanding the discourse on this ubiquitous evaluation tool.

This book is not meant to be a series of chapters dedicated to best practices for creating rubrics, nor is this text meant to present all sides of the rubric discussion. Rather, this text intends to offer critical polemics about rubrics that can spur greater critical discussion about a phenomenon in education that has largely been unquestioned in the literature.

Table of Contents:

Foreword, Joel Westheimer.

Introduction: Why a Book on Rubrics? Problematizing the Unquestioned, Joseph E. Flynn, Jr., Michelle Tenam-Zemach, and Leslie David Burns.

Chapter 1. The Rubricization of Experience, Michelle Tenam-Zemach.

Chapter 2. The Rubricization of Teacherhood and Studenthood: Intertextuality, Identity, and the Standardization of Self, Nancy G. Patterson and Lisa M. Perhamus.

Chapter 3. Collision Course: Postmodern Progressive Composition Pedagogy and Positivist Traditional Assessment, Amy L. Masko.

Chapter 4. Rubrics Reframed: Reappropriating Rubrics for Assessment and Learning, Paul Parkison.

Chapter 5. The Sanctity of Software and Rubrics as Holy Interfaces: A Critical Software Analysis of Rubrics as Vehicles of Education Reform, Tom Liam Lynch.

Chapter 6. Standards, Rigor, and Rubrics: Prefabricated Critical Thinking, Robert Boostrom.

Chapter 7. Employing a Technology of Power: An Orientation Analysis of a Teacher Task Rubric, Conra D. Gist.

Chapter 8. Rubrics in Context, Dana Haraway and David Flinders.

Chapter 9. (Dis)positioning Learners: Rubrics and Identity in Teacher Education, Catherine Lalonde, David Gorlewski, and Julie Gorlewski.

Chapter 10. Collaboration, Rubrics, and Teacher Evaluation, Susan Dreyer Leon and Laura Thomas.

Chapter 11. Getting Teacher-Evaluation Rubrics Right, Kim Marshall.

Chapter 12. The Danielson Framework for Teaching as an Evaluation Rubric: One Size Fits None, Leslie David Burns.

Chapter 13. Racing the Unconsidered: Considering Whiteness, Rubrics, and the Function of Oppression, Joseph E. Flynn, Jr.

Chapter 14. An Afterword in Two Voices: The Tools of Destruction and Empowerment: Reflections on Creating a Book About Rubrics, Michelle Tenam-Zemach and Joseph Flynn.

About the Editors.

About the Contributors.