The Routledge Handbook of Ethics in Forensic Linguistics by Nick, I. M.; Blewitt, Kirsty E.;

Short description:

The Routledge Handbook of Forensic Linguistics Ethics is the first comprehensive reference work to explore the ethical dimensions of forensic language analysis across various contexts, including the courtroom, research, education, and publishing. It establishes much-needed ethical standards for researchers and practitioners alike.

Long description:

The Routledge Handbook of Forensic Linguistics Ethics is the first comprehensive reference work to explore the ethical dimensions of forensic language analysis across a range of applied and academic contexts.

With the use of linguistic and phonetic evidence now commonplace in legal investigations and court proceedings, questions of consent, bias, responsibility, and professional integrity have become increasingly urgent. This volume brings together over thirty original chapters by leading scholars and practitioners in forensic linguistics and speech science to critically examine these issues. Chapters span a wide range of research and practice settings, from expert testimony and investigative consultancy to academic publishing, teaching, and public engagement, addressing ethical questions across diverse linguistic and legal systems. The handbook offers both conceptual frameworks and practical guidance for researchers and practitioners navigating the ethical challenges of forensic language work.

This authoritative resource is essential reading for scholars in applied linguistics, sociolinguistics, phonetics, law and language, criminology, forensic psychology, and legal studies.

Table of Contents:

1. Introduction - I. M. Nick. Section I: Providing Expertise as a Consultant. 2. The Integrity of Forensic Analysis - Robin T. Bowen. 3. Ethics and Professional Conduct Oversight in Forensic Linguistic Expert Evidence - Isabel Picornell. 4. The Expert’s Role in the Justice System is to Provide Impartial and Transparent Evidence, Not to Perform Social Advocacy - Richard Rhodes and Tina Cambier-Langeveld. 5. Ethical Issues Encountered in Forensic Linguistic Practice: Case Examples inspired by Real Life Cases - Tina Cambier-Langeveld and Richard Rhodes. 6. Maintaining Professional Distancing in Social Justice Cases of Non-Native Speakers - Margaret Van Naerssen. 7. An Intelligence Scaffold to Aid Ethical Considerations in Forensic Linguistic Casework - Ria Perkins, Sharon Glaas, and James Rosie. 8. Psychological Biasing in Forensic Linguistic Research: Is such information obtained expertly and ethically? - Ray Bull and Iris Blandón-Gitlin. 9. Countering Pseudolinguistic Claims: The Ethical Challenges Facing Forensic Linguists - Tanya Karoli Christensen and Sofia Beck Navarro. 10. Disinformative Linguistics: Using Linguistic Science for Unethical Purposes - Timothy Habick. 11. Ethics and Linguistic Practice of Dutch Police Interrogations: The Right to Silence - Martha Komter. Section II: Serving as An Expert Witness.12. Linguists and Lawyers: Ethical Challenges in An Adversary System - Robin Conley Riner and John Conley. 13. The US American Expert Witness and the Ethics of Advocacy - Michael O’Laughlin. 14. Challenging Legal Assumptions: Ethics, Due Process and Forensic Linguistic Research - Mel Greenlee. 15. The Forensic Linguist’s Ethical Duty to Explain Language Use to Triers of Fact - Dakota Wing. 16. The Golden Rule and the Golden Thread: The Ethics of Communicating the Criminal Standard of Proof - Chris Heffer. 17. Ethical Uncertainties and Inconsistencies in Diminished Responsibility Rulings: The Case for Fictionalism - Felicity Deamer and Sam Wilkinson. 18. Tightening the Rein on Expert Evidence: Ethical Reasons for Judicial Gatekeeping in the Canadian Context and Implications for Forensic Linguistics - Jennifer Glougie. 19. Ethical Expert Practice: Engaging with Everyday Linguistic Harms - Kelly Wright. 20. A Critical Evaluation of the Legal System in England and Wales for Sex Abuse Crimes Involving Adult Witnesses with an Intellectual Disability (AWID): Deliberations on Special Measures - Michelle Aldridge and Tina Pereira. 21. The Problematic Nature of L1 and Translation in US Criminal Courts: Access, Ethics and Errors - Mel Greenlee. Section III: Researching, Teaching, Publishing, and Providing for the Next Generation. 22. Too Close to Home?: Exploring Analysts’ Proximity to their Data - Grace Buker-Sullivan. 23. Navigating Legality, Linguistic rights, and Social Justice in Linguistic Research with Deaf Refugees - Nina Sivunen and Johanna Ennser-Kananen. 24. Ethical Research Practices with Highly Stigmatized Populations: Engaging with Individuals Convicted of Sexual Offenses - Stina Lindegren. 25. Ethical Considerations of Working with Political Extremist Threat Communications - I.M. Nick and Ulrike Preiss. 26. Ethical Considerations in Corpus-based Legal Interpretation Analysis. Brett Hashimoto and Derek Haderlie - 27. Get Your Hands Off My Idiolect! A Spectrum Model of Misuse of Idiolectal Information as a Heuristic Tool - Peter Harrison and Dom Watt. 28. Analyzing the Language of Non-Human Animals: Why Should Forensic Linguists Care? - Meike de Boer. 29. “So this is how you can manipulate witnesses!”: Ethical considerations in the teaching and dissemination of research in forensic linguistics - Karoline Marko. 30. Teaching Sensitive Topics in Forensic Linguistics: Ethical Implications for Students and Lecturers - Sam Larner. 31. Welcome Forensic Linguists!: Ethical Forensic Linguistics Pedagogy and Classroom Practice - Christine Jacknick and M. Peregrine Balmat. 32. Ethics and Publishing in Forensic Linguistics: Policing Credibility - Sarah Frances Gordon and Bernardo Turnbull Plaza. 33. Diversity in Forensic Linguistics: A Call To Fulfill the Promise - I.M. Nick. 34.  Concluding Thoughts - I.M. Nick.